• WisBusiness

Monday, February 10, 2014

Tom Still: A little about a lot: Patent lawsuits, jet fuel from plants, angel investing and more

By Tom Still
A little about a lot of things:

The Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation isn't the only organization accusing Apple Inc. of infringing on a high-tech patent. A few days after WARF filed suit against the technology giant, a Texas-based company did the same based on a different complaint.

WARF, the patenting and licensing arm for the UW-Madison, filed suit Feb. 3 in U.S. District Court in Wisconsin's Western District, alleging Apple infringed on discoveries by four professors. At issue is whether Apple's A7 processor – used in the iPhone 5S, the iPad Air and the iPad mini with Retina display – incorporates technology developed by Gurindar Sohi and three others in 1998.

Hilltop Technology LLC filed suit against Apple a few days later, accusing the company of infringing on Hilltop's work in developing a "Capacitive Type Touch Panel" used in touchscreen devices and modules.

With a reported $140 billion in cash on hand, Apple is a big litigation target. Then again, Apple can outlast and outspend most challenges to its intellectual property, whether it feels the allegations are fishing expeditions or not. An exception to that legal war of attrition could be WARF, which has $2.4 billion in assets and has proven in past infringement cases it's up to the fight.

Both lawsuits are reminders of why patent fights should remain a province of the federal courts, not state-based laws and litigation – a recent and somewhat troubling trend, especially for entrepreneurs who worry about losing their intellectual property to the big guys.

Federal courts have the expertise and experience to handle complicated patent suits; state courts do not. Such suits are about interstate commerce, not intrastate disputes. The Patent Act of 1790 deliberately put the federal government, not the states, at the center of intellectual property management. That precedent should stand.

* A San Diego company called SGB is exciting the biofuels world through its success in modifying a drought-resistant species of plants – jatropha – to produce high-quality seed oil that can be turned into low-carbon jet or diesel fuel.

The buzz may well be justified, given the plant's natural hardiness and genetic breakthroughs that promise the production of commercial qualities of oil. However, another high-flying firm much closer to home is also on the flight path for plant-based jet fuels.

Madison-based Virent Energy is using the carbohydrate portion of plants, such as corn stover, to produce test quantities of two jet fuels. Both Virent products are considered identical to petroleum-based fuels because of their freezing points, boiling points and thermal stability. That means they can be safely "dropped in" to the existing refinery infrastructure. Oil from jatropha plants must be further refined before it can be used as fuel.

Which process is better? Investment dollars and market acceptance will tell, perhaps more so than technology. However, the prospect of biofuels competing with conventional fossil fuels may mean there's room for both in the aviation industry.

Just following up…

* Former Gov. Tommy Thompson's transformation from politician to businessman was the subject of a December 2013 column. Through Thompson Holdings, he has invested in or is advising about 30 companies, mostly in health care technology but largely outside Wisconsin. Thompson will talk about his plans to get more involved in Wisconsin companies at the Feb. 13 meeting of the Wisconsin Innovation Network in Wauwatosa. Learn more or sign up to attend at http://www.wisconsintechnologycouncil.com.

* Another December 2013 column focused on Boeing's search for a place to build the 777x jetliner, and how Wisconsin's siting bid in Milwaukee drew upon the state's deep but little-known aerospace expertise. As many observers predicted, unionized Boeing workers grudgingly accepted the company's contract offer and the 777x plant will stay in the Seattle area. Wisconsin officials expected that might happen, too, so the bid didn't contain hard-and-fast numbers about tax incentives and other financial lures. That's just as well. There's no advantage in tipping the state's hand to the next suitor.

* Reports on Wisconsin's venture capital rankings vary depending on how the numbers are reported, but two recent reports speak to the continuing strength of the state's angel investors. Angels often invest in startups as individuals or through networks, long before venture capitalists enter the picture. The latest Halo Report by the Angel Capital Association identified Wisconsin Investment Partners in Madison as one of the nation's most active angel groups for the third quarter of 2013. Another report by Xconomy cited Wisconsin's Act 255 investor tax credits program as one of the nation's best. Since 2005, about $60 million in tax credits have generated nearly $250 million in private investments in 160 eligible Wisconsin companies.

-- Still is president of the Wisconsin Technology Council. He is the former associate editor of the Wisconsin State Journal in Madison.


Comments: 0

Post a Comment

Back to BizOpinion main page

: See newer blog items : : See older blog items :

BizOpinion site feed

wisbusiness.com Social News

Follow Us

Site Sponsors


· January 2009
· February 2009
· March 2009
· April 2009
· May 2009
· June 2009
· July 2009
· August 2009
· September 2009
· October 2009
· November 2009
· December 2009
· January 2010
· February 2010
· March 2010
· April 2010
· May 2010
· June 2010
· July 2010
· August 2010
· September 2010
· October 2010
· November 2010
· December 2010
· January 2011
· February 2011
· March 2011
· April 2011
· May 2011
· June 2011
· July 2011
· August 2011
· September 2011
· October 2011
· November 2011
· December 2011
· January 2012
· February 2012
· March 2012
· April 2012
· May 2012
· June 2012
· July 2012
· August 2012
· September 2012
· October 2012
· November 2012
· December 2012
· January 2013
· February 2013
· March 2013
· April 2013
· May 2013
· June 2013
· July 2013
· August 2013
· September 2013
· October 2013
· November 2013
· December 2013
· January 2014
· February 2014
· March 2014
· April 2014
· May 2014
· June 2014
· July 2014
· August 2014
· September 2014
· October 2014
· November 2014
· December 2014
· January 2015
· February 2015
· March 2015
· April 2015
· May 2015
· June 2015
· July 2015
· August 2015
· September 2015
· October 2015
· November 2015
· December 2015
· January 2016
· February 2016
· March 2016
· April 2016
· May 2016
· July 2016
· August 2016
· October 2016
· December 2016
Copyright ©2013 WisBusiness.com All rights reserved. | WisOpinion.com | WisPolitics.com  |  Website development by wisnet.com LLC  | Website design by Makin’ Hey Communications