• WisBusiness

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Is your organization ready to pay $6 million for an employee background screening mistake?

By Scott Paler
A recent class action settlement for $5.9 million with First Transit, Inc. reinforces the need for employers to review their background screening forms and procedures to ensure compliance with federal and state laws.

The quick version—the plaintiff walked away with a smooth $5.9 million, which left First Transit, Inc., gasping for air over their purported mistake of violating the Fair Credit Report Act. The long version—in Hunter, et al v. First Transit, Inc., the plaintiff argued the inclusion of a release of liability in the background screening disclosure and authorization form violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act’s (“FCRA”) requirement that the form stand alone. The plaintiff also alleged that the employer failed to follow a three-step process required under the FCRA before rejecting job applicants based on their background screening report. After completing some fact discovery on the allegations in the complaint, the plaintiff obtained a lucrative settlement.

The case signals a new litigious trend in the employment arena. Five to ten years ago, there were very few employment cases related to gathering and use of background screening information. However, times are changing. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is now pursuing several highly publicized class actions alleging that the use of background screening information disproportionately impacts minorities. In addition, there are several well-known plaintiffs’ firms now seeking out background screening cases on their websites with the belief that procedural violations of the FCRA could give rise to lucrative class actions. Anecdotally, we have also seen an increase in single-plaintiff cases before the Wisconsin Equal Rights Division related to employers’ use of criminal history information.

To limit the risks associated with background checks consider taking the following steps:
  1. Ensure that your background screening consent form stands alone.

    Among other things, the consent form, or “disclosure and authorization form,” should not be incorporated into an employment application or stapled to an employment application. It should be presented to applicants or employees as a separate document. Also, to the extent you currently include a release of liability in your disclosure and authorization form, it would be prudent to remove it. In order for the disclosure and authorization to be effective, it should be separate, conspicuous, and clear.

  2. Only consider criminal history information that is substantially related to the job.

    Wisconsin is one of the country’s most restrictive states with respect to employers’ use of criminal history information. In Wisconsin, state law only allows employers to consider criminal convictions that are “substantially related” to the position. Therefore, you should not institute a policy (or practice) of rejecting all felons or all individuals previously convicted of a crime. Instead, make a case-by-case assessment as to whether a particular conviction is substantially related to the job.

    Here are some general rules of thumb for complying with Wisconsin law. In our experience, violent offenses directed towards non-family members, fraud, perjury, and theft can be linked by employers to most positions. However, domestic offenses, driving offenses, and some drug offenses are less likely to be found “substantially related,” absent unique circumstances. Other offenses may fall somewhere in the middle. In addition, the less recent the offense, the less weight it should be accorded. Finally, keep in mind that you should generally not consider arrest records where the underlying arrest did not result in a conviction.

    Federal law requires employers to exercise caution where the use of criminal history information has a disparate impact on those in protected classes. For the most part, though, Wisconsin employers who diligently comply with Wisconsin’s “substantial relationship” requirement will be well-positioned to defend against disparate impact suits under federal discrimination laws.

  3. Only consider credit reports for select positions, or not at all.

    Since the recession, the use of credit reports by employers has become very controversial. The EEOC has suggested that employers’ reliance on credit reports is problematic whenever it has a disparate impact on minorities or members of a protected class. In fact, the EEOC has filed several class actions related to the use of credit reports by employers. Although Wisconsin is not currently among the group of states that has legislated restrictions on employers’ use of credit reports, that too could change in the next few years.

    For the time being, you should be cautious about using credit reports to the extent you receive any material number of applications from minorities or members of a protected class. The conventional wisdom is that employers should only consider credit information for those seeking high-level financial positions or cash-handling positions. However, even that is subject to challenge. As with criminal history, your analysis of credit history information should focus on whether the individual’s track record substantially relates to the job.

  4. Follow the three-step process required by the Fair Credit Reporting Act if you plan to take employment action based upon a background screening report.

    If you are considering rejecting an applicant or taking another employment action based upon a background screening report, make sure to abide by the procedural requirements in the FCRA. First, send a pre-adverse action letter to the employee or applicant stating that you are contemplating making an employment decision based in whole or part on a background screening report. Along with this letter, you should enclose a copy of the background screening report and a federal government notice entitled “A Summary of Your Rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.”

    Second, after providing the pre-adverse-action materials wait a reasonable period of time to allow the applicant or employee to identify inaccuracies or mistakes in the report that could potentially change your mind. At least one opinion letter from the Federal Trade Commission has suggested that five business days is reasonable, so that is the minimum amount of time recommended.

    Third, after the waiting period, remember to send an adverse action letter indicating that you are taking the action previously disclosed to the applicant or employee. Note that the FCRA requires specific content in the adverse action letter to appraise the individual of some of his or her rights under federal law, so make sure to check out the statute before you draft the letter. See 15 U.S.C. § 1681b(b)(3). Among other things, the letter must: (1) identify the name, address, and toll-free telephone number of the background screening company; (2) state that the background screening company did not make the decision and is unable to provide the consumer the specific reasons why the actions were taken; and (3) indicate that, upon providing proper identification, the individual may receive a free copy of the report and may also dispute the accuracy or completeness of the report with the background screening company.
Given the new class action and single-plaintiff risks associated with the use of background screening reports, Wisconsin employers are well-advised to audit their process for conducting background checks, consult with an attorney to ensure that legally compliant forms and procedures are being used, and reach out to counsel before excluding applicants or employees based on a background screening report.

-- Paler is an employment attorney practicing at the law firm of DeWitt Ross & Stevens. He routinely counsels employers on background screening issues, has helped defend employers’ background screening practices before administrative or judicial bodies in Wisconsin, New York and Michigan, and has written numerous articles and presentations on background screening compliance matters.


Comments: 11

At May 13, 2017 at 4:55 AM, Blogger anh Dong Luong said...

Cập nhật xo so moi ngay| hôm nay nhanh nhất
Cập nhật xo so quoc te| hôm nay nhanh nhất

At July 23, 2017 at 9:23 PM, Blogger Best Game for US said...

This is quite educational arrange. It has famous breeding about what I rarity to vouch. Colossal proverb. This trumpet is a famous tone to nab to troths. Congratulations huis te koop Spanje on a career well achieved. This arrange is synchronous s informative impolites festivity to pity. I appreciated what you ok extremely here.

At February 11, 2018 at 10:12 AM, Blogger Julia Jhonson said...

yes you are right... i agree with you...That is the proper weblog for anybody who wants to search out out about this topic. You understand a lot its virtually exhausting to argue with you (not that I truly would need匟aHa). You positively put a brand new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, simply nice! 2nd mortgage loans

At February 23, 2018 at 8:17 AM, Blogger Julia Jhonson said...

I have read you post, Great work you really did it very well. Keep working like this and sharing informative posts like
this one. keep it up. I'm waiting for your next post...
port colborne real estate

At March 17, 2018 at 6:28 AM, Blogger Julia Jhonson said...

Great tips I have noted all in my diary I'll use your all tips as you mentioned I really like your article I was searching on this topic as I'm working on this topics too.you can see my work but yours is too good I personally appreciate you for this. Keep working like this.custom shirts london

At January 5, 2019 at 5:14 AM, Blogger Coinpublish said...

Coinpublish cryptocurrency news Coinpublish ICO news Coinpublish Latest Blockchain news Coinpublish Bitcoin news Coinpublish Ethereum news Coinpublish Altcoin news

Coinpublish cryptocurrency news Coinpublish ICO news Coinpublish Latest Blockchain news Coinpublish Bitcoin news Coinpublish Ethereum news Coinpublish Altcoin news

At February 19, 2019 at 2:35 AM, Blogger Boozeey said...

Looking for best bars in Delhi to quench the weekend thirst, or just need some of the best pubs in delhi for enjoying evenings after long days at work. Choosing a place drink eBay celebrate should not be a difficult task. There are some things that are important while deciding about where shall you drink. The bar or the clubs should be close, economical, not congested & should also offer good food. But how can you find this information? It's actually quite simple. Just Download Boozeey Smartphone app for your smartphone.

boozeey will immediately give you the list of best bars in Delhi from the nearby area & show you their drinks menu & prices. So never waste time ever again by going to multiple bars or pubs, #justBoozeey. Not only does the boozeey app helps you to find the best pubs & bars it will also give you great discounts with features like first drink free every night & happy hours anytime. Check it out on App Store & Google Play & discover for yourself the easiest & the most economical way to enjoy parties at best bars in Delhi.

Not only your party experience is better with -boozeey but Boozeey takes care of a safe ride home for you. The Boozeey app has in-built OLA cabs integration that will allow you to book an OLA cab to reach or depart from the bar location. So if you are living in Delhi NCR download the -boozeey app & enjoy exclusive access to best bars & pubs in Delhi.

At March 7, 2019 at 1:02 AM, Blogger Seema Singh said...

Great post by you. Looking forward to some more.
canon printer support phone number
hp printer support number
epson printer support phone number

At May 1, 2019 at 7:21 AM, Blogger Rachel Adams said...

Roadrunner support phone number
outlook support phone number
yahoo email support phone number
Microsoft edge support Phone Number
Mozilla firefox support phone number
comcast customer support number
HP Printer Support Phone Number
Canon Printer Support Phone Number

At May 7, 2019 at 2:02 AM, Blogger Rachel Adams said...

geek squad tech support phone number

At May 29, 2019 at 9:47 PM, Blogger Service Center Apple said...

SpreadtrumSP Flash ToolStock RomBest Online StoreBaterai TanamBuku Servis HPKredit HPToko OnlineHP HangKomponen HP


Post a Comment

Back to BizOpinion main page

: See newer blog items : : See older blog items :

BizOpinion site feed

wisbusiness.com Social News

Follow Us

Site Sponsors


· January 2009
· February 2009
· March 2009
· April 2009
· May 2009
· June 2009
· July 2009
· August 2009
· September 2009
· October 2009
· November 2009
· December 2009
· January 2010
· February 2010
· March 2010
· April 2010
· May 2010
· June 2010
· July 2010
· August 2010
· September 2010
· October 2010
· November 2010
· December 2010
· January 2011
· February 2011
· March 2011
· April 2011
· May 2011
· June 2011
· July 2011
· August 2011
· September 2011
· October 2011
· November 2011
· December 2011
· January 2012
· February 2012
· March 2012
· April 2012
· May 2012
· June 2012
· July 2012
· August 2012
· September 2012
· October 2012
· November 2012
· December 2012
· January 2013
· February 2013
· March 2013
· April 2013
· May 2013
· June 2013
· July 2013
· August 2013
· September 2013
· October 2013
· November 2013
· December 2013
· January 2014
· February 2014
· March 2014
· April 2014
· May 2014
· June 2014
· July 2014
· August 2014
· September 2014
· October 2014
· November 2014
· December 2014
· January 2015
· February 2015
· March 2015
· April 2015
· May 2015
· June 2015
· July 2015
· August 2015
· September 2015
· October 2015
· November 2015
· December 2015
· January 2016
· February 2016
· March 2016
· April 2016
· May 2016
· July 2016
· August 2016
· October 2016
· December 2016
Copyright ©2013 WisBusiness.com All rights reserved. | WisOpinion.com | WisPolitics.com  |  Website development by wisnet.com LLC  | Website design by Makin’ Hey Communications