• WisBusiness

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Latest roadblock to embryonic stem cell research hurts everyone -- even its opponents

By Tom Still
Erik Forsberg, the executive director of Wisconsin’s WiCell Research Institute, may soon be running the scientific equivalent of a homeless shelter.

If a recent court ruling forces some of Wisconsin’s stem-cell researchers to abandon their federally funded laboratories and equipment, those researchers may find temporary quarters in WiCell’s research center near the UW-Madison campus. Because the WiCell lab isn’t backed by federal dollars, it could serve as a safe harbor for researchers whose labs run short on money.

“We’re debating what we can do if this legal situation is prolonged, but we can be a bridge for a period of time for some people,” Forsberg said. “We can be a stop-gap solution for some, for a while.”

Uncertainty has returned to the field of human embryonic stem-cell research, which has lived most of its short history in a stop-and-start environment uncharacteristic of almost anything else in science. The latest twist came in late August when U.S. District Court Judge Royce Lamberth issued a temporary injunction blocking the federal government from implementing National Institutes of Health guidelines governing embryonic stem cell research.

The injunction, which is being appealed, puts at risk more hundreds of research projects nationally – including many in Wisconsin, where UW-Madison researcher James Thomson was the first in the world to keep embryonic stem cells alive and unchanged indefinitely.

The ruling came after adult stem cell researchers and other plaintiffs protested President Obama’s 2009 order lifting federal funding restrictions. The judge concluded that federal funding for embryonic stem cell research violates a 1996 law that prohibits use of federal money for research in which an embryo is destroyed. The ruling drew sharp dissent.

“The injunction threatens to stop progress in one of the most encouraging areas of biomedical research, just as scientists are gaining momentum – and squander the investment we have already made,” said Dr. Francis Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health. “(The ruling) could cause irreparable damage and delay potential breakthroughs to improve care for people living with serious diseases and conditions such as spinal cord injury, diabetes or Parkinson’s disease.”

The NIH director also disputed the plaintiffs’ claim – accepted by the judge – that more federal funding for embryonic stem cell research means less money for adult stem cell work. Collins confirmed that NIH still funds about three times as much adult stem cell research as it does research with embryos.

Opponents say the ruling means scientists should go back to using adult stem cells, which have been researched since the mid-1960s, or speed the development of reprogrammed adult cells that have been genetically engineered to revert to an embryonic form.

Science doesn’t work well by rolling back the clock. Adult stem-cell research has gotten a second wind due to breakthroughs with embryonic stem cells, and the reprogrammed adult cells (called “induced pluripotent” stem cells) have yet to prove as stable or as pliable as embryonic stem cells. It may take more years of work to make the induced pluripotent stem cells work like embryonic cells, if it can ever be done at all.

“The decision is a deplorable brake on all stem-cell research,” said Alan Trounson, president of the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine. “Many discoveries with other cell types, notably the so-called reprogrammed iPS cells, would not happen without ongoing research in human embryonic stem cells.”

Expect California’s CIRM, which has already spent $1 billion on stem-cell research and is poised to spend $243 million more, to recruit researchers who may lose federal funding and whose states don’t offer state support.

“For now, the damage is mostly psychological,” said Forsberg of the court ruling, “but a lot depends on how long it takes for a reversal. We live in a competitive world, and if others see an advantage because of what’s happening in the federal courts, they’ll push ahead.”

The federal court ruling hurts researchers, who are once again mired in uncertainty. It hurts patients, who are losing time in the race for treatments and cures. It hurts states such as Wisconsin, which could see its researchers lured away by other nations or California. And, strangely enough, it hurts opponents, who wrongly believe adult stem cell research and iPS research can move ahead without human embryonic stem cells for side-by-side comparisons.

Let’s hope the on-again, off-again world of stem cell research soon reverts to on again – and stays there.

-- Still is president of the Wisconsin Technology Council. He is the former associate editor of the Wisconsin State Journal in Madison.


Comments: 5

At August 31, 2010 at 1:50 PM, Blogger zeus said...

Most Americans understand that no one lives forever and it is not worth gaining a few extra or even "many" years yet forfeit one's soul. Sorry but some people are more concerned about doing the right thing even if it's to our own fleshly demise.

At January 21, 2017 at 3:49 AM, Blogger bettycyoung said...

good Capacity to control Power Point discussions SHAREit for PC SHAREit is offered for most of the os such as Android, best.

At March 12, 2017 at 6:38 AM, Blogger kathiencarroll said...

good are looking is over and below you will get every possible https://itubedownloadappz.com more regarding iTube for PC after that your are at finest nice.

At April 24, 2017 at 6:17 AM, Blogger KellieWilliams said...

including functions like capture, discover, as well as book mark mobdro free app Today in this blog post I will primarily let you recognize the best ways to download Mobdro Apk.

At May 28, 2017 at 11:44 PM, Blogger Brown Boss said...

Today in this blog post I will primarily let you recognize the best ways to download Mobdro Apk. Download ES File Explorer proincluding functions like capture, discover, as well as book mark


Post a Comment

Back to BizOpinion main page

: See newer blog items : : See older blog items :

BizOpinion site feed

wisbusiness.com Social News

Follow Us

Site Sponsors


· January 2009
· February 2009
· March 2009
· April 2009
· May 2009
· June 2009
· July 2009
· August 2009
· September 2009
· October 2009
· November 2009
· December 2009
· January 2010
· February 2010
· March 2010
· April 2010
· May 2010
· June 2010
· July 2010
· August 2010
· September 2010
· October 2010
· November 2010
· December 2010
· January 2011
· February 2011
· March 2011
· April 2011
· May 2011
· June 2011
· July 2011
· August 2011
· September 2011
· October 2011
· November 2011
· December 2011
· January 2012
· February 2012
· March 2012
· April 2012
· May 2012
· June 2012
· July 2012
· August 2012
· September 2012
· October 2012
· November 2012
· December 2012
· January 2013
· February 2013
· March 2013
· April 2013
· May 2013
· June 2013
· July 2013
· August 2013
· September 2013
· October 2013
· November 2013
· December 2013
· January 2014
· February 2014
· March 2014
· April 2014
· May 2014
· June 2014
· July 2014
· August 2014
· September 2014
· October 2014
· November 2014
· December 2014
· January 2015
· February 2015
· March 2015
· April 2015
· May 2015
· June 2015
· July 2015
· August 2015
· September 2015
· October 2015
· November 2015
· December 2015
· January 2016
· February 2016
· March 2016
· April 2016
· May 2016
· July 2016
· August 2016
· October 2016
· December 2016
Copyright ©2013 WisBusiness.com All rights reserved. | WisOpinion.com | WisPolitics.com  |  Website development by wisnet.com LLC  | Website design by Makin’ Hey Communications