• WisBusiness

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Judging judges and voters fairly


By Bill Malkasian
In Wisconsin, judges and justices are elected by the people. Our Constitution requires it. The people must therefore be able to freely support candidates of their choice.

Last week the Wisconsin Supreme Court voted to reaffirm this basic principle and we applaud them for it. So should every Wisconsin citizen.

After hearing a wide array of legal, emotional and political arguments from a diverse and sincere set of individuals and organizations, the court made a very simple but important ruling by clarifying that judges cannot be forced off a case solely because of legal campaign contributions or endorsements they received during an election.

By ruling that lawful campaign contributions or endorsements alone cannot force a judge off a case, the court showed respect for both judges and voters.

Judges may still recuse themselves, for whatever reasons -- including campaign contributions -- if they feel they cannot be fair or impartial or if they feel sitting on the case will give that impression. Voters can now fully participate in judicial elections without fear that exercising their right to do so -- by making legal contributions or publicly supporting candidates -- will forcibly preclude judges from doing their jobs.

Critics of the court's decision, including some in the media, argue the entire Constitutional premise of electing judges should be thrown out.

They favor appointing judges, having taxpayers pay for judicial campaigns, adopting rigid contribution thresholds that force judges off cases, or some combination of these approaches. Still others argue we should do nothing now and just study the matter more.

While these larger systemic issues should be debated, the court rightfully ruled on the more narrow, more immediate issue of what is permissible under our current system. That's why the court did the absolute right thing, in time for the judicial elections this spring -- elections that Wisconsin has held for 150 years.

We should be proud of our Supreme Court for their thoughtful consideration of this difficult issue.

The justices had to consider the First Amendment rights of individuals and organizations to participate in elections and the due process rights of litigants to receive a fair and impartial hearing before a court. These are both fundamental rights and weighing them can be a tough balancing act.

While this court and others will be wrestling with the numerous remaining issues regarding recusal for many years to come, the court did the right thing by clearly saying voters have the First Amendment right to support judicial candidates of their choosing, and judges have the right to accept that support without being forced off cases for merely doing so.

We applaud the court for judging both judges and voters fairly.

-- Malkasian is president of the Wisconsin REALTORS Association (WRA), a trade association representing over 14,000 real estate brokers, sales people and affiliates statewide. The WRA, joined by 10 other major statewide organizations, petitioned the Supreme Court to amend the Code of Judicial Conduct's rules on recusal to address the issue of legal campaign contributions.

Labels:


Comments: 0

Post a Comment

Back to BizOpinion main page

: See newer blog items : : See older blog items :

BizOpinion site feed
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

wisbusiness.com Social News

Follow Us

Site Sponsors

ARCHIVE

· January 2009
· February 2009
· March 2009
· April 2009
· May 2009
· June 2009
· July 2009
· August 2009
· September 2009
· October 2009
· November 2009
· December 2009
· January 2010
· February 2010
· March 2010
· April 2010
· May 2010
· June 2010
· July 2010
· August 2010
· September 2010
· October 2010
· November 2010
· December 2010
· January 2011
· February 2011
· March 2011
· April 2011
· May 2011
· June 2011
· July 2011
· August 2011
· September 2011
· October 2011
· November 2011
· December 2011
· January 2012
· February 2012
· March 2012
· April 2012
· May 2012
· June 2012
· July 2012
· August 2012
· September 2012
· October 2012
· November 2012
· December 2012
· January 2013
· February 2013
· March 2013
· April 2013
· May 2013
· June 2013
· July 2013
· August 2013
· September 2013
· October 2013
· November 2013
· December 2013
· January 2014
· February 2014
· March 2014
· April 2014
· May 2014
· June 2014
· July 2014
· August 2014
· September 2014
· October 2014
· November 2014
· December 2014
· January 2015
· February 2015
· March 2015
· April 2015
· May 2015
· June 2015
· July 2015
· August 2015
· September 2015
· October 2015
· November 2015
· December 2015
· January 2016
· February 2016
· March 2016
· April 2016
· May 2016
· July 2016
· August 2016
· October 2016
· December 2016
Copyright ©2013 WisBusiness.com All rights reserved. | WisOpinion.com | WisPolitics.com  |  Website development by wisnet.com LLC  | Website design by Makin’ Hey Communications